In one of my favorite Gene Hackman films, Heist, there is a scene where his character is explaining how he solved a problem. His client (actually, a mobster he is planning to rip off) says, "you're a pretty smart guy." When Hackman's character declines the compliment, the mobster replies, "then how did you figure it out?" Hackman's response:
"I said to myself, 'what would a smart guy do?'"
I love that line. Unfortunately, I recently forgot that lesson. Let's set the stage. I am updating a new Primavera P6 schedule for the first time. I have a change order modification that has been added, and there is also progress on this new activity.
The client told me he is 40 percent complete with the modification. So I type in that percentage. And I move on with the update. But while checking my customized earnings report I realize there is no Earned Value for the new activity. But the activity is in fact showing 40% complete.
Okay...
Now, perhaps you are thinking I forgot to apply an actual start date. Well, no, it would not be possible to show a percent complete without first entering an actual start date. I should also mention that I am using the Physical % Complete type so that I can enter whatever percentage I want.
Hmm. Perhaps there is something wrong with the way I cost-loaded the activity. Nope, it has a budgeted total value. And I am using the same resource that all other cost-loaded activities have been assigned in this particular schedule.
What about my Earned Value settings? I almost never change them, but I verified that Performance Percent Complete = Activity % Complete (Admin > Admin Preferences > Earned Value). In the construction industry that is pretty much the setting that everyone uses. The point being that the activity percent complete determines Earned Value.
Yet here I am, still looking at zero dollars earned and 40% complete.
Aha, must be the activity type! We know that certain activity types like Level of Effort and WBS Summary behave differently than other types of activities.
Sorry - the new activity is Task Dependent. Nothing to see here folks. And if you were thinking it was a milestone, keep in mind that milestones cannot be assigned resources due to their zero durations.
What would Gene Hackman do?
He'd probably say something like, "hey buddy, if Earned Value is working on EVERY other activity in the schedule then there has to be something different about this one."
But it's not different, it's just new.
Oops...
Yes, it is a new activity! And where does Earned Value come from?
The baseline to the current schedule!
Under the Settings tab in the Project Details window there are two options for calculating Earned Value: Project baseline or User's primary baseline.
My schedule was set to Project baseline, and my Project baseline is the original plan. The new activity doesn't exist in the original plan so Earned Value is automatically zero.
I knew this, of course, but it is easy to forget when you are in a hurry. And it seems rather odd that users who never create baselines for the current project are immune to this potential problem. Because when there are no baselines the current schedule IS the baseline!
This is in my mind one of the most counter-intuitive aspects of Primavera P6. Earned Value is not always based on the current schedule. Why would I want to base my earnings on something other than the current schedule? If the budget has changed it seems logical to pay off the new budget.
Now, I prefer not to change the value of an existing activity for pretty much the same reason I don't change the original durations. I want to preserve the old values for future reference. If the duration or budget is changed by a modification I will add a new activity for that purpose.
I have had a few projects, however, where we re-balanced the activity budgets. Assigning any baseline other than the current schedule would clearly cause problems. Which brings up another concern: the Earned Value for a project can be okay one day and off the next if a different baseline is assigned. Fun!
When I mention this during training sessions I often hear someone with a little Primavera P6 experience say something like, "never happens to me". Yes, that could be true. If you don't typically create baselines then by default your baseline is the current schedule. Lucky you!
Those of us who utilize baselines on a regular basis have to be more careful. And it gets rather complicated when there is more than one baseline attached to the current schedule. Re-assigning a baseline can change Earned Value. Oh well. I'll just keep channeling Gene Hackman.